Monday, April 18, 2011


Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother
Written by Amy Chua

After watching an interview with author Amy Chua on the Today show promoting her latest book Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, I was immediately intrigued and appalled! I just could not understand a woman that frowns on playdates and sleepovers, who does not allow her children to choose their own extracurricular activities and who forces her children to practice a classical instrument 6 hours a day! However, I think I was most offended by her constant criticism of Westerns and their parenting styles. Therefore, when a local book club suggested that this book be the topic of discussion this month, I became a very eager participant. I bought the book with the assumption that my initial impression of this woman would be justified. In addition, I couldn’t wait to express my contempt to the fellow members of my new book club!

To my surprise, though, I found a kinship to Amy Chua. In her book, she gives a very candid account of her struggles with parenting the Chinese way in America. She discusses her loneliness in defending her values, the arborous work of preparing her children for the future and the battles that emerged between her and her family. I must say, I found her honesty quite endearing.

Also, I discovered I agreed with many things in the book! I, myself, limit the amount of TV my children watch. I have intentionally steered my children toward activities that will benefit them in the future (Although, I do not think Amy Chua would agree with the activities I chose) furthermore I do believe in hard work and expect the same from my children.

However, where we disagree is with the concept of playdates. I am a teacher and I strongly believe that social development is just as important as academics. I believe this difference of opinion is cultural, for in America, a person will not go far in their career if they do not have social skills no matter how intelligent they are.

I enjoyed this book and I applaud Amy Chua for her frankness, bravery and determination. As an American, though, I have to say I did not appreciate the constant criticisms and overgeneralizations about Westerners and their parenting styles that she expressed so strongly in every chapter. There are many hard working Americans who do not “eat junk food and spend 10 hours a day on Facebook.” Perhaps, she is just meeting the wrong people.

What do you think of the Tiger Mother? Enter to win this book in this months Giveaway and decide for yourself!

ENTER TO WIN Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother

~ Simply be a follower of this blog or become one! Then leave a comment to this post to add your name to the drawing. BE SURE TO ADD YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS SO I CAN CONTACT THE WINNER!

This giveaway will end on MaY 15, 2011 The winner will be chosen by Random drawing from all valid entries submitted. The winner will be notified via email and will have up to 48 hours to contact me with their mailing address before another winner is chosen. Open world wide! No P.O Boxes please.

Good Luck!
Michelle Berg
Little Nipper Books


  1. Thank you for the giveaway! I am a follower!

    wenzowsa at canisius dot edu.

  2. I've been intrigued with what I've read about this book - it's certainly been a topic of conversation in our house... My husband is South African, so I think some of the observations of Americans resonate with him! I'm with you on the play dates, though.

    janemaritz at yahoo dot com

  3. The book sounds intriguing. I'm a new folllower by name of dancealert.

    dancealert at aol dot com

  4. I'm not a parent but I do teach preschool. I read an excerpt and had a strong negative reaction. I think I need to read the entire book. After your review, I'm thinking it would definitely be worth my time.

  5. Hi Michelle:

    I'm not entering your contest as I already have this book. I just wanted to comment that I too read it and absolutely loved it. Amy Chu did a fantastic job and I found that I agreed with most of what she said. They are quite strict when raising their children and don't put up with any guff like a lot of parents do today with their children. Perhaps all of us who are raising children, could take a few lessons from this book.

    I'm signing up as a follower today and maybe you'd like to follow my blog as well as:


  6. I've been hearing a lot about this book. Although I'm sure I will have a strong negative reaction, I nonetheless want to read it. I have a young daughter(6 in June).

    I found out about your giveaway on Bea's Book Nook.

    GFC(Mona Garg)

  7. New follower on GFC :) I share your curiousity with this title and would love to read it. Thanks for the chance to win a copy!


    ruralmoms AT gmail DOT com

  8. The generalizations of Americans is painful. Enjoyed your review.

    I follow you now.

  9. please include me in this giveaway thanks

    ABreading4fun [at] gmail [dot] com